Patients at risk

07 April 2014
Volume 29 · Issue 10

The Dental Law Partnership is calling for tighter monitoring of the quality of the work of NHS dentists.

This is after it discovered that the body responsible for assessing risk to NHS dental patients, the NHS Business Services Authority (NHSBSA) had examined just 160 dental patients last year (2012-13).

The NHSBSA is a Special Health Authority and an Arms-Length Body of the Department of Health.

It is tasked with providing central services to NHS organisations, contractors, patients and the public. Part of that remit includes visiting and assessing dental practices where potential risk has been identified.

The aim of the NHSBSA is to support Primary Care Organisations monitoring performance of dentists and the care of patients.

However, figures provided by the Dental Law Partnership (DLP) revealed that during the same 12 month period that the NHSBSA only managed to examine 160 patients, DLP took on 820 new dental negligence claims.

Latest figures from the General Dental Council show that there are currently 39,258 registered dentists in the UK, who are responsible for treating NHS patients

Chris Dean, managing director of DLP, said: “The relatively small number of NHS patients being checked on behalf of the Department is worryingly low.  The NHSBSA states that it operates a risk-based monitoring system, so only visits NHS dental practices where concerns have been raised.

“But based on the number of negligence cases that we have taken on over the same period, we feel that the organisation is barely scratching the surface in terms of checking patients around the UK potentially at risk from poorly performed NHS treatment.

“It’s completely baffling that a team of 11 advisors could only collectively manage to see 160 patients in a year.  Especially when you consider that a single typical NHS dentist may examine or treat up to 150 patients a week.

“The figures calls in to question the value of the service being provided by the NHSBSA and raises major concerns about the lack of effort being put into monitoring the performance of dentists.” 

Katherine Murphy, chief executive of the Patients Association, commented: “It is worrying that the NHS Business Services Authority has examined only 160 dental patients in the past year. Patients need to know that if they wish to complain about their local dentists, that the authorities will properly investigate the treatment that dental surgery provides.  Otherwise they will lose confidence in the system, allowing bad dentists to continue practicing for far longer than they should do.  

“The NHS Business Services Authority needs to demonstrate to patients that they are taking seriously the concerns over dental practices that are made to them.

“There is an urgent need for better monitoring systems and swift action on poor providers. It is ultimately the patient who is at the receiving end of poor quality of dental care,” she added.